A Eulogy to my Favorite Pizza
It is with painful sorrow that I announce the departure of a thing most loved. My favorite pizza place has gone away. Again.

When I was a little kid growing up in Ohio, there was no better pizza treat than Godfather’s Pizza. I still remember the commercials to this day. One of them had the Godfather (an Italian Mafia-looking guy) in a jail cell wearing his striped coveralls, ordering up his final meal of delicious pizza. Godfather’s was a treat to be taken seriously, because it was a rare thing for my family to eat out. Besides that, the pizza was absolutely amazing, and the atmosphere of the place — new inventions called “arcade games” in the parlor — was a dream for a kid like me. I have so many fond memories.
Sadly, when I was about 10 or so, Godfather’s was bought out locally by a company called Showbiz Pizza, which is still around in some places. Unfortunately, the Godfather’s in my home town, and indeed the entire Midwest (to my knowledge) was simply shut down and sold off to other businesses. My favorite pizza place became some sort of card and gift shop, and I was relegated to the greasiness of Pizza Hut for the rest of my life. It was a travesty, and I was sad.
Fast forward about twenty-odd years. My friend calls me excitedly one day and tells me that we need to plan a trip to Chillicothe, Ohio. Chillicothe was about a 45-minute drive south of where I lived in Columbus, and is basically a redneck, white-trash heaven. Of course I asked, “Why would I want to go there?” “Pizza,” he exclaimed. “You want Godfather’s pizza.”
True to his word, Chillicothe contained an owner-operated franchised Godfather’s Pizza. It was hot and cheesy and delicious and every bit as awesome as I remembered as a kid. Even better, I was an adult now and could eat it whenever I wanted. Of course, there was a drive involved, so I rationed it out. Still, it was bliss.
A couple of years later, I moved here to Salt Lake City. Imagine my delight when I discovered that Godfather’s was still alive and well in the western states, and that there were several within a short drive from my apartment! Never again would I have to stomach Pizza Hut, and there would be delicious Godfather’s for the taking whenever I felt the urge. Suddenly, a childhood memory and longing desire became an everyday reality. It couldn’t get much better.
December, 2008: A month that will live in infamy. For whatever reason, (I blame the economy), Godfather’s Yummy Pizza has completely abandoned the Salt Lake area, and the entire state of Utah. Both eat-in locations, and all three carry outs have closed. I drove by today, tearing up at the sight of the “Space Available” banner covering the once beautiful sign that promised perfect pizza pleasure. My stomach gurgled, signaling its own sigh of sympathy at our mutual loss. My taste buds felt dull, and my tongue ached for the wonderful sauce, cheese, and pepperoni perfection. Once again, cruel fate has intervened and taken away a cherished indulgence.
Now comes the search for something else. I don’t know where to get pizza now. Sure, there’s always Dominos or Papa Johns. If I’m desperate enough, there are a few Pizza Huts floating around. Of course, there are the local places too. Who knows? Maybe I’ll find something, someday.
But nothing will replace my Godfather’s. I knew thee well, and will miss you.
